November 16 2026, 20:52
Saving Agnes
I finished this a week ago, but I’ve been putting off writing up these notes, possibly because I’m working on my next novel again, and part of my rationale for posting notes on books at all was to get me thinking more intentionally about writing. This was Cusk’s debut novel, just like The Complex was mine, and I think I was looking for clues on what early career books can be like. Sadly, Saving Agnes is rather excellent, and Cusk was writing better at twenty-six than me at fifty-three. Yes, I’m back on my comparison bullshit again.
Agnes Day lives with two university friends, Nina and Merlin, in a north London house that has a growing crack in a load-bearing wall. This instability runs all through Agnes’s life, from her low-level publishing job at Diplomat’s Week, to her emotionally distant boyfriend(s), to her strained relationship with best friend Nina, and her increasingly mad parents and combative brother. Agnes is unable to read other people’s intentions, and is hopelessly naive about relationships. To shake herself out of an identity crisis, she has to learn to become more assertive.
The first half of the book impressed me, but also left me cool on Agnes’s dilemmas. I wonder if being in my fifties made it a touch harder to relate to Agnes’s twenty-something frustrations. She doesn’t know who she is or what she wants to do with her life, and as an older reader the stakes don’t seem sufficiently high, although that might also be the point. Agnes puts herself through the wringer trying to understand why men are so awful to her, personal interactions are so awkward, and she feels like she’s always in the wrong.
Cusk makes many of these scenes amusing and even outright funny. The story hits its stride in the second half, building to a surprising reveal and eventually an emotional climax. I did doubt Agnes/Cusk, I won’t lie, but I shouldn’t have–she was a genius from the very beginning.
Previous: Shades of autumn