November 20 2026, 21:49
Providence
After reading Anita Brookner’s A Start in Life in April, I knew I’d move on to her second novel, Providence, before the year was out. I picked it up alongside Rachel Cusk’s Saving Agnes, which has a similar autofictional element, although Brookner, who wrote hers as a much older writer, denied it was remotely autobiographical until much later in her career. All three books follow a female protagonist in her twenties having a crisis of identity and trying to find her way in the world.
Kitty Maule is an academic at an illustrious university (Cambridge?) teaching the Romantic movement. She is in love with Maurice Bishop, Professor of Medieval History, who keeps her at a distance and sends her mixed signals. Maurice travels to France to research medieval cathedrals, and Kitty arranges to meet him in Paris, but she struggles to understand what precisely she wants and what is being offered. Meanwhile, she has an important lecture to write, and she is troubled by her elderly parents.
The novel spends a great deal of time exploring Kitty’s longing for companionship, especially with Maurice. The men seem unknowable to Kitty, and she’s far happier talking to women. Her neighbour, Caroline, divorced and always looking for Kitty’s company, is a flamboyant counterpoint to Kitty’s exact manner. Pauline Bentley is a fellow lecturer who spends her home life looking after her ailing but still formidably intelligent mother. Some of Kitty’s more important insights come from the unlikely Madame Eva, a clairvoyant Caroline introduces her to. That’s how desperate she becomes to understand Maurice’s intentions.
Kitty’s grandmother, Louise is a skilled dressmaker, and one of the late chapters shows her, along with Kitty’s grandfather Vadim, make the dress that Kitty wears to her inaugural lecture. The novel opens with the family’s story of arriving in England from France, and the death of Kitty’s mother and father. She knew her mother, but her father died before she was born, and that longing to know him leaves Kitty exposed to the dangers of projection in romantic love.
Previous: Saving Agnes